How to read a MST assessment

How to read an MST assessment – CSR Italia

The assessments published by CSR use the Multi-System Tension Framework (MST)

to observe the structural state of the main geopolitical macro-areas. The framework does not assess the severity of a single event.

A crisis, a conflict, a political decision or an economic shock can have a strong media impact without significantly changing the structural configuration of a macro-area.

Conversely, gradual and persistent changes can alter the balance of the system over time even in the absence of particularly visible events.

MST assessments therefore describe the structural state of the macro-area observed in the analysis cycle under consideration.

Four main indicators are used:

—-> MST Score
—-> MacroBase
—-> ICA (Adaptive Capacity Index)
—-> FC (Convergence Factor)

MST Score

The MST Score is the summary measure of the overall systemic pressure observed in the macro-area.

On the macro-area pages the MST Score is also referred to as the Macro Score.

The value does not describe a single event, but the configuration resulting from the interaction of the main structural tensions present in the regional system.

In general terms:
lower values indicate systems with greater absorption capacity;
higher values indicate systems subject to persistent, multi-domain pressures.

The MST Score makes it possible to track the evolution of the same macro-area over time and to compare, in relative terms, the positioning of the different geopolitical areas analysed by the framework.

MacroBase

The MacroBase identifies the prevailing systemic configuration of the macro-area in the analysis cycle.

It does not measure the probability of a specific event, but the shape taken by the observed structural pressures.

The main configurations used by the framework are:

Sustainable Pressure
Tensions are present but remain contained and show no significant capacity to spread.

Latent Accumulation
Pressures are growing, but have not yet developed a stable convergence across different domains.

Systemic Friction
Tensions are persistent, spread across several domains and begin progressively to erode the system’s absorption margin.

Critical Convergence
Pressures tend to align across different domains, significantly reducing the resilience of the macro-area and increasing the risk of systemic spread.

Systemic Breakdown
Configuration characterised by the critical synchronisation of pressures and the loss of containment capacity at system level.

The configuration is determined by the MST Score, on a scale from 1 to 5:
Sustainable Pressure 1.0–2.0;
Latent Accumulation 2.0–3.0;
Systemic Friction 3.0–4.0;
Critical Convergence 4.0–4.5;
Systemic Breakdown 4.5–5.0.

When the score coincides with the boundary between two bands and the cycle records no changes, the configuration of the previous cycle is retained as long as the score, rounded to two decimal places, remains the same; at the first change the band is reassigned. The macro-area pages state this explicitly.

ICA - Adaptive Capacity Index

The Adaptive Capacity Index (ICA) measures the macro-area's ability to absorb, manage and contain the structural pressures observed across the different domains.

The indicator does not assess the severity of a single event, but the overall resilience of the regional system.

Higher values indicate a greater ability of the macro-area to isolate and contain the pressures present.

Lower values, by contrast, indicate a weaker adaptive capacity and greater systemic fragility.

The ICA therefore makes it possible to assess how far the regional system is able to withstand the observed tensions without generating significant discontinuities.

FC - Convergence factor

The Convergence Factor (FC) measures the degree of transmission of pressures across different domains.

This indicator makes it possible to assess whether a tension originating in a specific domain is generating measurable effects in other areas of the regional system.

Higher values indicate a greater capacity for pressures to propagate and generate systemic effects.

The FC does not measure the intensity of pressure itself, but rather its capacity for transmission within the macro-area.

Structural pressure and net pressure

``` For each of the six domains — security and military postures, energy and infrastructure architectures, financial and monetary circuits, regulatory and normative standards, the cognitive and informational domain, technological-industrial ecosystems — the framework measures the observed structural pressure and the net pressure, which takes adaptive capacity into account. When adaptive capacity is lower than the pressure, the net pressure is higher than the structural pressure. A net pressure equal to or above 4.8 in a domain signals a condition of critical compression (Domain Breakdown Threshold). ```

How to read an Assessment

No indicator should be interpreted in isolation.

A macro-area may display a high MST Score while still maintaining a satisfactory containment capacity if pressures remain separated and the system retains adequate adaptive capabilities.

Conversely, a macro-area with a lower level of pressure may become more vulnerable when tensions begin to converge and propagate across different domains.

For this reason, the MST framework simultaneously evaluates:

the intensity of pressures;
the systemic configuration;
adaptive capacity;
multi-domain transmission.

From regional level up to global system

Assessments of individual macro-areas constitute the foundation of the Global System Assessment (GSA).

The GSA integrates the configurations observed across different regional systems and provides a synthetic assessment of the condition of the international system during the analytical cycle under consideration.

While macro-area assessments describe the structural pressure affecting individual regional systems, the GSA evaluates their interaction at the global level.

What does the MST framework measure

The MST framework is not a predictive model.

It does not forecast specific events and does not assign probabilities to individual crises.

Its aim is to identify configurations of accumulation, convergence and systemic compression that may change the stability of the macro-areas and of the international system over time.

An event enters the measurement only when it produces persistent effects documented by multiple sources; events occurring after a cycle has closed are assessed in the following cycle.

The framework does not measure what happens.

It measures the structural conditions that make certain developments more or less likely over time.

Framework version: MST v3.2 · GSA v3.1