Israel and the West: Alliance, Dependence, and Influence

Israel and the West: Alliance, dependence, conditioning

This analysis is part of a series dedicated to the role of Israel in the contemporary international system, structured across three dimensions: territory, region, and its relationship with the West.

—> General Introduction to the series
—> Israel as a systemic actor in the Middle East
—> The Invisible Annexation

How the West Bank illustrates the silent transformation of territorial control in the contemporary international system

Israel and the West no longer represent a simple privileged relationship between ally and protector.
In the contemporary international system, this relationship must be understood as a structure of asymmetric interdependence, in which alliance, dependence, and influence overlap without fully coinciding. Israel depends on the West, particularly the United States, for strategic protection, military support, and diplomatic cover.
But the West also depends on Israel as an intelligence hub, a platform for regional power projection, and a forward strategic outpost in one of the most sensitive regions of the international system.
This relationship generates advantages, but also political costs and constraints on decision-making.

Israel and the West no longer represent a simple privileged bilateral relationship.
In the contemporary international system, this relationship must be understood as a structure of asymmetric interdependence, in which alliance, dependence, and influence overlap without fully coinciding.

Israel is not merely an ally of the West.
It is one of the points where the relationship between regional security, Western power structures, and the decision-making constraints of advanced democracies becomes particularly visible.

Interpreting the relationship between Israel and the West as an automatic reflection of historical and political affinities is no longer sufficient. Today, that relationship must be understood in terms of power, interdependence, and mutual constraints.

Israel as Both Ally and Constraint

Israel depends on the West, and primarily on the United States, for strategic protection, military support, diplomatic cover, and the preservation of its qualitative military advantage.

But the West, and Washington in particular, also depends on Israel as an intelligence hub, a platform for regional power projection, a source of military innovation, and a forward strategic outpost in one of the most sensitive regions of the international system.

The relationship is therefore not linear. It is not simply a matter of protector and protected. It is a relationship in which protection generates influence, but influence does not eliminate mutual dependence.

This is where the first decisive point emerges: Israel is both an ally and a constraint.

The Role of the United States

For the United States, Israel remains a force multiplier for its presence in the Middle East. It provides political access, military cooperation, intelligence integration, and an understanding of the regional strategic environment that few other partners can offer.

Yet this very centrality makes it more difficult for Washington to approach the region without being constrained by domestic and international political costs.
Every crisis involving Israel tends to narrow America's room for manoeuvre, transforming a regional decision into a question of global strategic credibility.

The alliance therefore produces an ambivalent effect. It strengthens US power projection while simultaneously reducing Washington's ability to clearly separate American interests from Israeli interests.

Europe and the Strategic Cost of the Relationship

The same applies to Europe, although in a different form. European countries do not maintain the same deeply institutionalised relationship with Israel as the United States, but they are nevertheless exposed to its strategic consequences.

Crises involving Israel affect European capitals through at least four channels: security, energy, domestic polarisation, and diplomatic pressure.

In security terms, the connection is indirect but real. Crises involving Israel reshape the priorities, postures, and strategic sensitivities of the Western alliance.

In energy terms, they affect perceptions of regional risk and the vulnerabilities of logistical corridors.

At the political and cognitive level, they generate polarisation within European societies, reactivate identity-based divisions, and make it more difficult to establish a stable common position.

At the diplomatic level, they force Europe to confront its limited coercive capacity and the gap between declared principles and its actual ability to exert influence.

Israel thus also becomes a mirror of Western contradictions.

Israel and the West as a Factor in Decision-Making Constraints

The West asserts the primacy of rules but struggles to translate that principle into consistent behaviour when a strategic ally is involved.

It formally supports the two-state solution but lacks shared instruments capable of meaningfully influencing the trajectory of the conflict.

It calls for regional stability while remaining structurally exposed to crises that this very relationship helps make more sensitive.

This does not mean that the West is captive to Israel. It does mean, however, that the relationship with Israel acts as a multiplier of tensions within the West itself.

In the United States, this dynamic is particularly evident. Israel is not merely a foreign policy issue. It is also a matter of domestic politics, consensus-building, and the relationship between the strategic establishment, public opinion, Congress, and the national narrative.

For this reason, every decision concerning Israel operates simultaneously on two levels: the regional order and domestic political competition in the United States.

Influence and Decision-Making Timeframes

Developments in 2025–2026 have reinforced this ambivalence. Military and intelligence cooperation remains exceptionally deep, but the political cost of the relationship is also increasing, particularly in the most polarised Western societies.

This is a trend, not an isolated event. And it has become part of the context in which the alliance operates.

From this emerges a second decisive effect: Israel influences the pace of Western decision-making.

Western democracies tend to move slowly, seek compromise, and distribute the costs of decisions across institutions and public opinion.

Israel, by contrast, often operates according to a logic of strategic urgency, threat anticipation, and the minimisation of exposure to risk.

When these two political timeframes intersect, the result is structural tension. Israel pushes for rapid decisions. The West tends to respond through slower and more contradictory processes.

The relationship does not break down, but it becomes more rigid.

Epic Fury: When Influence Becomes Joint Action

On 28 February 2026, the dynamic described in this article found its most radical expression. Netanyahu exerted direct pressure on Trump to undertake joint military action against Iran; on the basis of Israeli intelligence described as a decisive factor, Washington authorised Operation Epic Fury (Roaring Lion for Israel). During the strikes, Iran's Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei was killed and was subsequently succeeded by his son Mojtaba on 8 March.

This event moves the Israel–West relationship beyond the framework of political influence described so far. It is no longer a matter of Israel narrowing the West’s room for manoeuvre through a crisis that Washington is forced to manage; it is a jointly planned operation involving the physical elimination of the leadership of a third state. In this case, the distinction between an ally that exerts influence and an ally that jointly makes decisions has effectively dissolved.

A ceasefire mediated by Pakistan came into effect on 8 April, but proved fragile: renewed clashes between 7 and 8 June, a US–Iran memorandum of understanding signed on 17 June (providing a 60-day window for formally ending the conflict), and further exchanges of attacks through late June demonstrate that the crisis remains open, not resolved. For Europe, this episode intensifies precisely the dynamic described in the previous section: an operation in which European capitals did not participate, but whose consequences they nevertheless bear in terms of energy security (the Strait of Hormuz), diplomatic pressure, and domestic polarisation.

Israel as a Node of Systemic Activation

For this reason, too, Israel cannot be viewed solely as a beneficiary of Western protection. It is also an actor capable of setting priorities, accelerating decisions, narrowing the space for ambiguity, and compelling Western partners to respond in areas they might not otherwise have independently identified as priorities.

This is where the concept of influence comes into play.

Influence does not imply complete control. It does not mean that Israel absolutely determines the conduct of the West.

Rather, it means that its strategic position, its capacity for initiative, and the nature of its relationship with Washington ensure that, once involved, the West cannot treat the crisis as something external to itself.

Israel therefore acts as a node of activation, not merely as a protected ally.

This function becomes particularly clear when the Israeli strategic theatre intersects with broader issues: Iran, the Red Sea, proxy actors, nuclear deterrence, the stability of Arab partners, NATO postures, energy security, and global cognitive polarisation.

In all these cases, the Israeli question can no longer be confined to the regional sphere and becomes a variable capable of influencing the entire Western decision-making architecture.

Conclusion

For this reason, the relationship between Israel and the West cannot be reduced to a moral, ideological, or identity-based formula. It is a relationship of power, interdependence, and mutual constraints.

Israel receives support, but also generates political costs. It receives protection, but also sets priorities. It receives diplomatic cover, but also influences the strategic posture of its allies.

The strategic reality is more uncomfortable than simplistic narratives suggest: Israel is simultaneously a necessary ally, a challenging partner, and a factor constraining Western decision-making.

This explains why every crisis involving Israel tends to reveal something beyond the regional balance of power in the Middle East. It reveals the degree of Western coherence, the extent of genuine European autonomy, the limits of American freedom of manoeuvre, and the growing difficulty Western democracies face in reconciling principles, interests, and strategic credibility.

For this reason, the relationship between Israel and the West must be understood as one of the most sensitive strategic architectures of the contemporary international system. Not because it alone holds the key to global disorder, but because it demonstrates with particular clarity how a strategic alliance can simultaneously become an asset, a constraint, and a source of mutual influence.

It is precisely in this ambivalence that its systemic significance lies.

Update (July 2026):

Epic Fury demonstrates that this ambivalence can extend beyond mutual influence to joint military action and the direct sharing of its legal and political consequences, including the precedent of eliminating the leadership of a foreign state. The systemic significance of the Israel–West relationship must now also be assessed in this context, which remained unresolved as of 1 July 2026.

https://csr-italia.org/israele-e-loccidente/

Essential Sources

IISS, CSIS, Chatham House, Carnegie


These three dimensions do not exhaust the Israeli case, but they allow us to understand how an actor can simultaneously operate across territory, region, and decision-making architectures.



Further reading: the updated MST assessment of the macro-area. Middle East.

Explore the series:

Access to protected content within the CSR framework