The Invisible Annexation

The Invisible Annexation

This analysis is part of a series dedicated to the role of Israel in the contemporary international system, structured across three dimensions: territory, region, and its relationship with the West.

—> General Introduction to the series
—> Israel as a systemic actor in the Middle East
—> Israel and the West: alliance, dependence, and constraint

How the West Bank illustrates the silent transformation of territorial control in the contemporary international system

Abstract / Summary

In the contemporary international system, territorial transformations rarely occur through formal declarations of annexation. Increasingly, the control of a territory is consolidated through gradual processes, distributed over time and built through administrative, infrastructural, and demographic instruments.

The West Bank represents one of the most obvious cases of this dynamic. Here, the change did not occur through a single political or legal act, but through a cumulative sequence of decisions that, over time, changed the geography of the conflict.

For this reason, the West Bank should not be read solely as one of the most sensitive nodes of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, but as a case study of contemporary geopolitics.

The invisible annexation as geopolitical logic

In the international system of the 21st century, a formal annexation tends to produce almost automatic diplomatic reactions, political isolation, and, in some cases, sanctions.

An incremental transformation of space, on the other hand, allows for substantial territorial results by distributing political costs over time and reducing the threshold for international reaction.

The logic of invisible annexation is simple: alter reality on the ground long enough and deeply enough to make it increasingly difficult to return to the previous situation.

The West Bank as a paradigmatic case

The West Bank clearly demonstrates this mechanism. Over the past decades, the territory has been progressively redefined through a combination of three main instruments.

The first is demographic transformation. The stable presence of civilian populations linked to the state that exercises control produces a territorial reality that is increasingly difficult to reverse without extremely high political, administrative, and social costs.

The second is administrative integration. The progressive extension of legal procedures, urban planning rules, infrastructure, and governing mechanisms creates an increasing overlap between a formally contested space and the administrative system of the dominant state.

The third is the reorganization of physical space. Roads, barriers, security devices, access networks, and systems of connection or separation do not merely manage territory; they redesign it. The geography changes before the legal framework changes.

The outcome of these three processes is cumulative. The territory is gradually transformed until it becomes increasingly politically impractical to return to the previous status. When the issue comes to the center of diplomatic debate, the transformation of the space has often already occurred.

Data and territorial transformation

In 2025 a historic record was set with the approval of 27,941 housing units in the settlements, according to Peace Now.

In March 2026, the OHCHR documented a further acceleration of the expansion and forced displacement of more than 36,000 Palestinians.

To these data are added further developments in the following months: in January 2026 the Israeli authorities published tenders for thousands of housing units in the so-called E1 area, which risk separating East Jerusalem from the rest of the West Bank and disrupting north–south territorial continuity; on February 8, 2026 the Israeli security cabinet ratified measures that facilitate land registration and property acquisition in the settlements by Israeli and foreign citizens; in June 2026 Amnesty International published a report that defines “ethnic cleansing” as the treatment reserved for the Bedouin and pastoral communities of the West Bank. These developments occurred largely in the same weeks when international attention was focused on the Epic Fury operation against Iran (February 28 – April 8, 2026) — a temporal coincidence consistent with the logic described in this same article, according to which incremental territorial transformations advance more rapidly when the threshold of international reaction is temporarily lowered by competing crises.

These data not only change the numbers on the ground; they also make the realization of a contiguous Palestinian state increasingly complex, both geographically and politically.

The limits of the international response

This case also reveals a structural limitation of the international system. Diplomatic and legal institutions are much more effective in responding to formal violations — declared invasions, official annexations, explicit changes in borders — than they are in dealing with slow, fragmented, and administratively distributed processes.

When territorial transformation proceeds in an accumulative manner, without a single moment of clearly identifiable rupture, the capacity for international reaction tends to weaken. The response thus remains confined to the declaratory dimension, while the material change of the territory continues.

In the Israeli-Palestinian case, this general limit is aggravated by specific political factors. TheEuropean Union continues formally to support the two-state solution, but lacks shared coercive instruments. The United Statesmaintain their role as Israel's main strategic guarantor. At the same time, several regional actors have progressively shifted their strategic centre of gravity towards confrontation with Iran, regional security and the stability of their own arrangements.

The result is a situation in which territorial transformation can continue without encountering international pressure that is truly capable of changing its trajectory.

The geographical crisis of the two-state solution

The most significant consequence concerns the very geographical basis of the two-state solution.

The network of settlements, infrastructure, and control systems fragments the Palestinian space, making the construction of a state entity with territorial continuity, administrative autonomy, and an effective capacity for governance increasingly complex.

In this context, the two-state solution continues to survive in diplomatic language, but it risks gradually losing its geographical feasibility.

A broader model of territorial control

However, the West Bank is not just a local case; it is also an example of a broader geopolitical model.

In recent decades, numerous territorial disputes have followed similar dynamics: the effective control of space is consolidated before its political or legal recognition. In different forms, cases such as Crimea, Donbass, Abkhazia, South Ossetia o Northern Cyprus show how territorial change can occur through progressive layering, making a return to the previous situation less and less reversible.

In all these cases, the strategic logic is the same: to alter the reality on the ground long enough and deeply enough to ensure that the law arrives too late in relation to the facts.

Conclusions

This dynamic signals a broader transformation in the ways in which states compete for control of space. Geopolitical change increasingly tends to manifest itself through slow, cumulative, and administratively distributed processes, rather than through sudden and formally declared ruptures.

For this reason, the West Bank should be read not only as one of the most sensitive nodes of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, but as a case study of contemporary geopolitics.

It shows how, in the 21st century, the struggle for territory does not always involve the proclamation of new borders; more and more often it involves the silent transformation of space.

And when this transformation becomes fully visible on the political level, the new geography is often already established.

Update (July 2026):
the January–June 2026 data confirm the acceleration described in the article. In addition to OHCHR and Peace Now, it is documented by Amnesty International's June 2026 report on the Bedouin and herding communities of the West Bank.

Essential sources:

 OHCHR, Peace Now, B’Tselem

These three dimensions do not exhaust the Israeli case, but they allow us to understand how an actor can simultaneously operate across territory, region, and decision-making architectures.



Further reading: the updated MST assessment of the macro-area. Middle East.

Explore the series:

Access to protected content within the CSR framework